《Harry Potter》Is Neville the prophesied boy and the reason for Voldemort's failure?

The recent hit TV series - Harry Potter - is deeply loved by the audience. Countless fans are not only fascinated by its ups and downs plot and vivid characters, but also full of curiosity and excitement about it.Among them - Harry Potter - whether Neville is the boy in the prophecy and the reason for Voldemort's failure is what everyone wants to know the most right now. Today the editor will talk about it with you.

《Harry Potter》Is Neville the boy from the prophecy?

In the Harry Potter series, there is an interesting Boy Who Lived theory involving the character of Neville Longbottom.Although Professor Trelawney's prophecy stated that Neville would not become the Boy-Who-Lived, some people have proposed the theory that it was Neville who was chosen.This theory suggests that Neville is often overlooked by teachers and classmates throughout the series, but he may actually play an important role as well.

In Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone, Neville demonstrates his courage and strength, able to face challenges alongside Harry, Ron, and Hermione, and even resist Voldemort.Not only was he a classmate of the Golden Trio, he also played a key role throughout the series, most notably in the destruction of Voldemort's final Horcrux, Nagini.

Although Harry is considered the Boy Who Lived and became a key figure in the fight against Voldemort, there are many theories that the prophecy also applies to Neville.The prophecy made by Professor Trelawney forced Voldemort to attempt to kill Harry, but the prophecy did not specify that Harry was the chosen one, and Neville was also a possible alternative.However, there is a theory that explains why Neville couldn't actually be the Chosen One.

How did Neville become the Chosen One?

Professor Trelawney revealed this possibility to Dumbledore in her prophecy.The prophecy spoke of a child born at the end of July 1980 who would have the power to defeat the Dark Lord.The key to the prophecy is that the boy's parents defied Voldemort three times, which is an important part of the prophecy.He will possess powers that Voldemort cannot fathom, and Voldemort will see him as his rival, a choice that will activate a prophecy in which one will be defeated and the other will survive.

However, Severus Snape only heard the first half of the prophecy and told the incomplete part to Voldemort.Therefore, Voldemort believed that Harry would fail him, without taking Neville into account.Neville was born one day earlier than Harry. His parents were members of the Order of the Phoenix. They had despised Voldemort, which was consistent with the description of the prophecy.

Furthermore, Voldemort did not hear the second part of the prophecy, and he did not know that it referred to his own destruction.Voldemort believed that he must find the person in the prophecy. If he knew the second half and chose to ignore the prophecy, then he would not have any connection with Harry Potter.

Neville couldn't be the “Boy-Who-Lived”?

While Neville may have been the Chosen One, there's a theory explaining why he couldn't be the “Boy-Who-Lived”.The reason Harry Potter was able to escape the Killing Curse was because of his mother's sacrifice.James Potter gave his life to protect Harry, but this did not activate the protective wards.The reason why Harry was able to survive was because Lily Potter was given a choice to survive. She resolutely chose to protect her son, while others did not get this opportunity.

Snape's love for Lily prompted him to ask Voldemort to protect her, and Voldemort temporarily kept his promise.However, Lily was unwilling to trade Harry's life for her own, but chose the opposite protection, which created a special protection mechanism that Voldemort didn't really understand.

If Voldemort had chosen Neville, he would not have had this protection, and he would not have been able to survive Voldemort's murder of him.Because Snape would not ask for Voldemort's protection for anyone else, Voldemort would not give the Longbottom family any chance of survival. He would ruthlessly eliminate them just like he did James Potter.

If Neville is chosen, will Voldemort succeed?

If Voldemort had chosen Neville as the “living boy” of the prophecy, he might have achieved his goal.Snape may not have told Dumbledore about the Old Devil's choice for various reasons, and whether he understood the full content of the prophecy.This means that Dumbledore may not use the Fidelity Charm to protect the Longbottom residence.Dumbledore was usually good at being prepared, so if he did take steps to protect the Longbottoms, their hidden guardian might not betray James Potter as much as he did.

However, Dumbledore may have believed that he was the only one who heard the prophecy, so he had no intention of placing the Fidelity Curse on the Longbottoms.If Voldemort chose Neville, he could easily defeat him as few wizards could match his power, not even Dumbledore.Additionally, Voldemort would have more time to craft Horcruxes, which would make him unstoppable, thus achieving his goals of eternal life and unlimited power.

How Voldemort failed because of his choices

After hearing the prophecy, Voldemort made critical decisions that ultimately led to his downfall.Voldemort's pride led him to choose Harry because Harry was a half-blood wizard like him, so he regarded Harry as his rival.Furthermore, Voldemort's choice to follow the prophecy was also the reason for his failure.Even if it was Neville who was chosen, once Voldemort acted on the prophecy, it would be difficult to prevent it from coming true.But because Voldemort only heard half of the prophecy, he had no idea what the consequences of his actions would be.

In Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire, Voldemort admits that he should have foreseen the ancient magic of Lily's protective ward.However, Voldemort was unable to understand magic and power like this, and because of this, Harry was saved many times in the series, such as by the Ministry of Magic in Order of the Phoenix.This problem was at the root of Voldemort's inability to succeed, and he chose Harry without ever truly trying to understand why Harry was able to resist his power.From the beginning of Harry Potter, his choices were destined to be the cause of his failure.

Another possibility after Neville is drafted

It was no accident that J.K. Rowling introduced the Chosen Neville theory, as many Harry Potter fans believe the plot could have gone many different ways.The prophecy stipulates the conditions for the five chosen people: male, parents who have defied Voldemort three times, born at the end of July, marked as an opponent by Voldemort, and possessing powers unknown to Voldemort.

While Harry was able to survive the Killing Curse because of Lily's sacrifice, little is known about the Longbottom family's relationship with other Death Eaters, meaning there may have been others raised in the name of one of Neville's parentspassed a request similar to Snape's, so it is theoretically possible to achieve a similar result to Harry.

An interesting Neville-the-chosen argument has been made by a veteran fan, suggesting that the powers Neville possesses may have more to do with Gryffindor than love.Harry and Neville were both students who pulled Godric Gryffindor's sword from the Sorting Hat, suggesting that Neville has a more special connection with one of the founders.

Furthermore, no one knows how differently Voldemort would have tried to kill baby Neville, as he did with Harry.Although Harry's parents are members of the Order of the Phoenix, and Neville's parents are excellent pure-blood wizards, this may cause Voldemort to be more hesitant when dealing with the Longbottom family, and other possibilities arise..I wonder what readers think about this issue?

Okay, this is all the content that the editor has compiled for you - Harry Potter - whether Neville is the boy in the prophecy and the reasons for Voldemort's failure. I believe you may also encounter it in the following storylines.Some parts are difficult to understand, so we recommend you stay tuned to the line lessons.In the future, we will provide you with more latest film and television plot analysis and character analysis to better understand and appreciate film and television works.